In
yet the latest fiery example of a crude-by-rail disaster, a derailment
on Thursday of a train carrying crude oil near the Mississippi River in
Galena, Illinois (not far from the Iowa border) saw several cars burst
into flames as thick black smoke billowed into the air.
Operated by the rail company BNSF, the company
said the train originated in North Dakota and was carrying more than a hundred cars of Bakken crude.
"The only thing more mind-boggling than three
such accidents in three weeks is the continued lack of action by the
Obama administration to protect us from these dangerous oil trains."
—Mollie Matteson, Center for Biological DiversityAccording to
Reuters:
Dark smoke was seen for miles around the crash site, and
the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency told local WREX.com that
two of the cars were potentially on fire. Images posted online by
Dubuque Scanner showed flames several hundred feet high, while aerial
footage showed the wreck spread across two sets of track.
The
train with 105 loaded cars - 103 of them carrying crude oil - derailed
around 1:20 p.m. CST (1920 GMT), according to a BNSF statement. The
incident occurred on what appears to be a major rail line alongside the
Mississippi River that handles as many as 50 oil-trains a week, one
official said.
"The sky is pretty dark down there, the smoke is
pretty black," said Kevin Doyle, whose property borders the tracks. "If
you're standing on the tracks you can throw a rock in the water."
The
Associated Press added:
Firefighters could only access the derailment site by a
bike path, said Galena Assistant Fire Chief Bob Conley. They attempted
to fight a small fire at the scene but were unable to stop the flames.
Firefighters
had to pull back for safety reasons and were allowing the fire to burn
itself out, Conley said. In addition to Galena firefighters, emergency
and hazardous material responders from Iowa and Wisconsin were at the
scene.
Noting that this is third such derailment in the United States in as
many weeks, environmental campaigners voiced immediate concern that
government officials have proven ineffective when it comes to curbing
the dangers posed by the large increase in crude-by-rail traffic in
recent years.
"The only thing more mind-boggling than three such accidents in three
weeks is the continued lack of action by the Obama administration to
protect us from these dangerous oil trains,"
declared
Mollie Matteson, a senior scientist at the Center for Biological
Diversity, in a statement on Friday morning. "The government has the
authority to take immediate action to address this crisis – which puts
homes, waters and wildlife at risk – and yet it has sat back and
watched."
On Thursday, an
exclusive investigative report by
Reuters
explained how last year, as a string of crude derailments had increased
public outcry and concern, the Obama contemplated—but ultimately
decided against—tightening federal regulations on the oil-by-rail
industry. Instead of having the federal government impose tougher
restrictions,
Reuters reported, the Obama administration decided to allow state regulators, in this case North Dakota, to set the rules.
According to Matteson, "There are simply no excuses left for the
Obama administration. The fact that these trains are still moving on the
rails is a national travesty. The next explosive wreck — and there will
be more, so long as nothing changes — may take lives, burn up a town or
level a city business district, and pollute the drinking water of
thousands of people. Enough is enough."
In its response to the latest derailment by a BNSF train carrying
crude oil, the public interest group U.S. PIRG on Friday noted that the
company
spent upwards of $5 million lobbying congressional lawmakers against tougher oversight in 2014.
Smoke
and flames erupt from the scene of a train derailment Thursday, March
5, 2015, near Galena, Ill. A BNSF Railway freight train loaded with
crude oil derailed around 1:20 p.m. in a rural area where the Galena
River meets the Mississippi, said Jo Daviess County Sheriff's Sgt. Mike
Moser. (Photo: AP/Telegraph Herald, Mike Burley)
Just as in a similar derailment that occured in West Virginia last
month, the rail cars in Illinois that caught fire were newer-model CPC
1232, touted by the industry as safer than older models still widely
used.
According to the
BNSF statement, all the tanker cars involved in Thursday's derailment
were the "unjacketed CPC-1232 model with half-height head shields."
Last month, citing internal data by the U.S. Department of Transportation,
the Associated Press revealed predictions by the government agency,
given current trends, that train derailments such as this will continue
to be commonplace in the years ahead, occurring at an average of 10
times a year, costing billions of dollars in damage, and putting a large
number of lives at risk..
Following Thursday's disaster,
Mother Jones was among the many news outlets making
note of the growing and troubling trend of what have euphemistically become known as "bomb trains":
The image of smoldering oil train cars is now a familiar sight: Incidences of exploding oil trains have been rapidly rising in North America thanks to the fracking boom in North Dakota's Bakken oil fields (Bakken oil is potentially more flammable than normal crude) and the slow transition away from old, unsafe rail cars. Oil-by-rail carloads are up 4000 percent from 2008 in the United States and this is the the third derailment in North America in the last three weeks, including a massive explosion in West Virginia on February 16 that injured one person and spilled oil into the nearby Kanawha River. In fact, a Department of Transportation report predicted
trains carrying crude and ethanol would derail an average of 10 times
per year in the next two decades. This is bad news for people who live
near railways and the ecosystems in which they reside.
In
an op-ed for
Common Dreams last month, Jared Margolis, a staff attorney for the Center for Biological Diversity and the author of a
recent report on the crude-by-rail crisis, echoed this point by writing:
The unprecedented increase in U.S. oil train traffic from
fewer than 10,000 rail cars per year in 2008 to more than 400,000 in
2014 has spurred virtually no corresponding increase in safety
preparedness plans, not only putting towns and cities across America in
routine danger, but leaving some of the nation’s most imperiled wildlife
and natural areas at increased risk from a catastrophic spill.
Even
as the overall number of train accidents in the country has declined in
recent years, the number of dangerous oil train derailments has
increased — in part because the longer, heavier trains, often carrying
more than 1 million gallons of oil, are more difficult to control and
stop, according to rail safety accounts included in today’s report.
In reality, Margolis concluded, there is "no way to safely transport
the highly volatile crude from the Bakken oil field in North Dakota or
the heavy crudes from the Alberta tar sands. Instead these extreme
fossil fuels should be left in the ground for our safety and to avoid
the impending climate catastrophe."